Discussing "Teaching Economics After the Crash" and a great blog post!

Few economics educators will have missed the December 2014 documentary by Aditya Chakrabortty on Radio 4 titled Teaching Economics after the Crash. It has likely been discussed in many an A level economics classroom, particularly with students eager to know more about their potential economics degrees...I know a couple of my classes watched it with interest and had many questions about their future economics degrees afterwards... Unfortunately, few asked "Is what the documentary said actually true?"

The documentary did lead to some fascinating discussions with both students and colleagues and whilst all found it enjoyable viewing, it was not particularly clear to enough students that it was a rather unfair and one-sided representation, and a portrayal that most economics degree courses do not typically deserve.

I felt that its unbalanced nature could not only have negative consequences in terms of the selections some students made in terms of their future study of economics, but it was also rather unfair in the way it misrepresented the truth about the nature of economics undergraduate degrees in general. It's general message was essentially that economics degrees aren't good enough at helping students understand the economies of the world (and typically the financial crisis) as they aren't well applied and they (the economics degrees) are delivering more of a right-wing, neo-classical doctrine as opposed to a balanced, applied and useful skill-set.

Now, rather than producing my own rebuttal, this article: Thoughts on “Teaching Economics After the Crash” by Karl Whelan does a wonderful and a far better job than I ever could. It provides an insight into the mind of a well-balanced economist and educator who can see the validity in some of the points raised and recognises that improvements can (and should) be made, and also tackles the unsupported, anecdotal critiques head on.

Not only does Karl Whelan carefully address the misconceptions but he also gives a window in to what students are likely to experience during their undergraduate economics degree, which is why we were discussing the documentary in the first place!

Comments

A chat with a world class economist...Jia Yi!

It is always great to hear how students are getting on as they progress through life, moving on to bigger and better things... Many of our students at GIS go on to study at some of the world's best universities and it was wonderful to hear from Jia Yi Lim, who recently moved from Malaysia to the USA and is now settling into life at Harvard University. When in Year 13, Jia Yi was over-the-moon to have received offers from Harvard, Stanford and Cambridge ...having only made 3 applications! Harvard was chosen in the end, but it was certainly a decision which took considerable time, a lot of thought and careful deliberation. In only her first semester at Harvard, Jia Yi is loving life. Having been fortunate enough to have taught her A Level Economics as well as enjoy watching her debate and witnessed her incredible community service work ( Project Smile ), I thought I knew what Jia Yi was capable of. However, her contributions so far at Harvard, as I am sure you'll agree, a...

What’s the difference between business and economics?

Every year, as we go through the Options process (IGCSE and A Level), parents and students alike have hundreds of questions. And rightly so, the decision is important. But one question we hear multiple times every year is: "What's the difference between business and economics?" ...and more often than not, this question includes accounting. This post hopes to shed some light on this and help explain the main differences. At GIS, we like to use an analogy given to us a few years ago by another economics teacher (Mr Stewart...credit where credit is Stew!)… First, let's talk about Business Studies . Business studies delves into the core areas related to businesses and their operations. The buying, selling, producing and marketing of goods and services. Imagine a business, let's say it is a factory. Visualise lifting the roof off and peering inside; you see four main sections each with very different things going on... In one area, there is a team of people using ...

Get ahead this summer - Read

The summer provides AS students the perfect opportunity to set themselves apart from other students and to get ahead, making their life that little bit easier for the A2 year. This might be in terms of being prepared for the A2 course but also for the all important university applications process, and the subsequent interviews... One excellent way students will set themselves apart is through reading. Universities say they want to see applicants reading relevant books that show they have an interest in the subject they wish to study. Imagine applying to do an economics degree having not read any books! It is not just about reading anything, it is about what you have read. So, to help you we have tried to provide you with some reading at various levels that should enable you to choose the appropriate books for you this summer. Don't forget, being up to date in terms of news and opinion is also critical so make sure you check out the further reading recommended in...

EconomicsToo

Search This Blog