Skip to main content

A dialexeis: Brexit negotiations kept secret from Parliament does reclaim sovereignty from Brussels


Tasked with a thought experiment known a 'dissoi logoi', a classical idea in rhetoric where one considers an issue from the perspective of an opponent's argument to better understand it, Year 13 economist, Zhou Chen has produced this piece (originally on his blog). 

Following a discussion on how 'sovereignty' was a major reason behind many 'Leave' votes and reviewing this article on sovereignty being 'reclaimed' but then the UK ignoring Parliament, Zhou Chen has produced the following on his blog:

Brexit negotiations kept secret from Parliament does reclaim sovereignty from Brussels

First and foremost, I acknowledge this is a strange and unpopular view but seemed like an interesting mental exercise to pursue. The idea that, as announced by Secretary of State for Leaving the EU David Davis, “Until Article 50 is initiated and Britain officially begins the process of leaving the European Union, no news on Brexit negotiations will be disclosed to the public, MPs or peers – not even in private” could mean reclaiming sovereignty from Brussels, is one which may indeed hold some water.

A major part of why many chose to leave the EU was the argument that Brexit would help reclaim their sovereignty which was so selfishly taken from them when they joined the EU. The hypocrisy lies in the fact that the largest mandate in history is being done behind the backs of parliament. But is it really?

Sovereignty is understood in jurisprudence as the full right and power of a governing body to govern itself without any interference from outside sources or bodies. In reality however, nothing is truly sovereign. The Brexit negotiation provides us a move towards increased sovereignty but it cannot bring us to total sovereignty. The process itself is not a black box from beginning to end, simply that much of the confidentiality will be time-related. Information will be communicated late just not in advance. And such a process is a move away from all the red tape Brussels has placed on the UK, towards a sovereignty that resides principally in the House of Commons and in its ability, when given the opportunity, to inform and direct the government of the day. Moreover, the secrecy is a necessity as a running commentary would simply undermine the negotiating stance from the beginning, keeping in mind the negotiations are a means to an end (to be more sovereign) rather than an end in itself by sacrificing perceived sovereignty in the short run for a more absolute one in the long run.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A chat with a world class economist...Jia Yi!

It is always great to hear how students are getting on as they progress through life, moving on to bigger and better things... Many of our students at GIS go on to study at some of the world's best universities and it was wonderful to hear from Jia Yi Lim, who recently moved from Malaysia to the USA and is now settling into life at Harvard University. When in Year 13, Jia Yi was over-the-moon to have received offers from Harvard, Stanford and Cambridge ...having only made 3 applications! Harvard was chosen in the end, but it was certainly a decision which took considerable time, a lot of thought and careful deliberation. In only her first semester at Harvard, Jia Yi is loving life. Having been fortunate enough to have taught her A Level Economics as well as enjoy watching her debate and witnessed her incredible community service work ( Project Smile ), I thought I knew what Jia Yi was capable of. However, her contributions so far at Harvard, as I am sure you'll agree, a...

What’s the difference between business and economics?

Every year, as we go through the Options process (IGCSE and A Level), parents and students alike have hundreds of questions. And rightly so, the decision is important. But one question we hear multiple times every year is:  "What's the difference between business and economics?" ...and more often than not, this question includes accounting. This post hopes to shed some light on this and help explain the main differences.  At GIS, we like to use an analogy given to us a few years ago by another economics teacher (Mr Stewart...credit where credit is Stew!)…   First, let's talk about Business Studies . Business studies delves into the core areas related to businesses and their operations. The buying, selling, producing and marketing of goods and services.  Imagine a business, let's say it is a factory. Visualise lifting the roof off and peering inside; you see four main sections each with very different things going on... In one area, there is a team of people using ...

Get ahead this summer - Read

The summer provides AS students the perfect opportunity to set themselves apart from other students and to get ahead, making their life that little bit easier for the A2 year. This might be in terms of being prepared for the A2 course but also for the all important university applications process, and the subsequent interviews... One excellent way students will set themselves apart is through reading. Universities say they want to see applicants reading relevant books that show they have an interest in the subject they wish to study. Imagine applying to do an economics degree having not read any books! It is not just about reading anything, it is about what you have read. So, to help you we have tried to provide you with some reading at various levels that should enable you to choose the appropriate books for you this summer. Don't forget, being up to date in terms of news and opinion is also critical so make sure you check out the further reading recommended in...